09/30/2008 (8:21 pm)
Host of factors contributed to bailout’s demise
Left- and right-wing lines in the sand, a partisan pre-vote speech by U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, overwhelming public distaste for helping Wall Street, lukewarm support from presidential candidates Barack Obama and John McCain and limited lobbying success from the Bush administration and business groups all doomed the $700 billion bank bailout Monday.
The $700 billion mortgage and bank bailout measure failed in the U.S. House of Representatives, pummeling economic confidence, as well as credit and financial markets.
The bill failed 228-205 with 133 Republicans and 95 Democrats opposing.
Only 65 Republicans voted in support, despite the bailout being engineered by the Bush White House and accompanied by dire economic warnings.
Many of the GOP critics, such as U.S. Rep. Tom Price of Roswell, Ga., had an underlying ideological opposition to the idea of the federal government taking on bad mortgages from lenders.
Price blasted the plan philosophically as an “egregious” undermining of American ideals and practically as an unacceptable hit on taxpayers.
“It is unfortunate that congressional Democrat leaders insisted on pushing through this fatally flawed plan instead of considering free market alternatives,” he said.
That free-market orthodoxy compelled a number of GOP “no” votes.
At the other end of the spectrum, Pelosi, D-Calif., is getting some of the blame for the defeat. Pelosi voted for the measure but House leaders, Democrat and Republican, didn’t put together a winning hand. The bailout defeat drowned financial markets Monday.
Pelosi also gave a charged speech before the House vote, blaming President Bush’s and Republican economic policies for the credit and finance disorder, saying they followed a “right-wing ideology” while hailing the Clinton administration. Banking deregulation and home ownership pushes blamed in part for the mortgage problems curently saddling banks, enjoyed support from the Clinton and Bush administrations, including some former Clinton economic aides now advising Barack Obama.
Pelosi also called the original plan forwarded by U.S. Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson and Federal Reserve Bank chairman Ben Bernanke “arrogant” and hammered home criticism of Wall Street executives’ compensation.
Despite supporting the bill, Pelosi spent much of her speech criticizing Bush policies and Wall Street and echoing some of the liberal criticisms of the bill online payday advance. She spent less time saying why she was supporting it.
Republicans said Pelosi’s speech and criticisms turned off some fence-sitting Republicans and emboldened more Democrats to vote “no” on the bill.
Ninety-five freshman, Hispanic and liberal Democratic lawmakers voted against the bill.
They have their own liberal laundry list they want in the bailout: more help for homeowners, money for community organizing groups that help distressed mortgage holders and a greater toll on Wall Street, including new taxes.
Public opinion polls and calls to congressional offices showed little backing for the bailout. Only two of the 13 Georgia representatives — Democrats Sanford Bishop of Albany and Jim Marshall of Macon– supported the plan. The other four Democrats in the delegation joined all seven Republicans in voting against it.
The partisan and orthodoxy-driven bailout failure prompted large stock market losses and increased worries of frozen credit rivers and more drowning banks and mortgage lenders.
“This legislation was a move that we believe would have restored confidence in the financial markets,” said Stephen E. Sandherr, CEO of the Associated General Contractors. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce and other business groups are also upset with the failed vote and its potential economic impact.
Democrats could return with a more liberal plan than the Bush proposal that was voted down Monday, including money for “community organizing groups,” new taxes on Wall Street and union membership guarantees on corporate boards.
Neither presidential rival, John McCain or Barack Obama, invested substantial political capital in support of the bailout. McCain somewhat sided with House Republican critics of the plan while Obama has used the mortgage and credit crisis to fault Bush’s economic plans on the campaign trail — a less strident echo of Pelosi.